It's essential to note that parliamentary immunity is not absolute and has limitations. It typically does not cover criminal acts unrelated to legislative duties, and lawmakers can still be held accountable for certain offenses once their immunity is lifted or in cases where the alleged actions fall outside the protected scope. The goal is to strike a balance between protecting legislators' ability to perform their duties and ensuring accountability within a democratic framework.
Explained: Why MPs/MLAs Get Legislative Immunity?
New Delhi (ABC Live): New Delhi (ABC Live): A seven-Judge Bench of Supreme
Court of India on March 4, 2024 unanimously held that a lawmaker does not enjoy
immunity under Articles 105(2) and 194(2) of the Constitution against bribery
in case titled Sita Soren v Union
of India.
Parliamentary
immunity, also known as legislative immunity or legislative privilege, serves
several important purposes in democratic societies. The key reasons behind the
establishment of parliamentary immunity include:
Freedom of Speech and
Debate: Parliamentary immunity protects legislators from legal repercussions
for their statements and actions made during official legislative proceedings.
This is crucial for fostering open and uninhibited debate within legislative
bodies. It ensures that lawmakers can express their opinions freely without
fear of being sued or prosecuted for their words.
Independence of the
Legislative Branch: Parliamentary immunity helps maintain the independence of
the legislative branch from undue influence or interference by the executive or
judicial branches. Lawmakers should be able to carry out their duties without the
threat of legal action designed to stifle their independence or intimidate
them.
Protection of
Democratic Process: By shielding legislators from certain legal consequences,
parliamentary immunity aims to safeguard the democratic process. Elected representatives
need the freedom to voice diverse opinions, represent their constituents, and
participate in decision-making without fear of legal retribution that could
hinder the democratic functioning of the government.
Avoidance of
Harassment: Parliamentary immunity protects lawmakers from potential harassment
through legal actions that may be brought against them for their official acts
or statements. This protection helps prevent strategic or politically motivated
legal challenges that could disrupt the legislative process.
Encouragement of
Public Service: Offering some level of immunity to legislators encourages
individuals to participate in public service by becoming lawmakers. Knowing
that they have a degree of legal protection can attract capable and committed
individuals to serve in legislative roles without the constant fear of legal
consequences for their official actions.
It's essential to note
that parliamentary immunity is not absolute and has limitations. It typically
does not cover criminal acts unrelated to legislative duties, and lawmakers can
still be held accountable for certain offenses once their immunity is lifted or
in cases where the alleged actions fall outside the protected scope. The goal
is to strike a balance between protecting legislators' ability to perform their
duties and ensuring accountability within a democratic framework.
Also, Read Explained:
How Immunity for Lawmakers Facing Bribery Charges Reached SC?